Round 5...

[Bandage Man]

Your role is:

"MURDERER"

[Bandage Man]

Questions:

1) How did you find the Death Match between Jay and Lukas?

2) What are your thoughts on Jay being the eliminated player?

3) What are your thoughts on the Main Match?

4) Do you like the role you are assigned?

5) Any strategy on how to go about the game?

[Joseph]

NOOOO WHY ME FML

my initial strategy of scumreading won't work anymore fuck.

i actually play mafia all the time at townofsalem. not sure if it'll work with this cast :L

[Joseph]

1) when its time to vote someone to the jail:

what happens when the vote is 4-4 and only 1 person did not vote? is their vote decided by random.org??? or does the vote become a tie and no one is sent to the jail?


2) does the main match start with night? or day?

[Bandage Man]

May 27, 2017 16:06:40 GMT -5 Joseph said:

1) when its time to vote someone to the jail:

what happens when the vote is 4-4 and only 1 person did not vote? is their vote decided by random.org??? or does the vote become a tie and no one is sent to the jail?


2) does the main match start with night? or day?

1) it is consider a tie as the person who does not vote only counted if one person has the majority.

2) main match starts with night round

[Joseph]

1) I found the DM confusing at first because I'm not familiary with this detective vs killer game. I saw it on the season 2 finale thread, but didn't really follow along. This time around I understood it somewhat with the positioning/actions potentially revealing a player's identity.

2) I was so disappointed because having Lukas out of the game would be a big boon for me personally. Now that I'm in a team with Lukas it seems better but I'm afraid of him as a competitor.

3) YAS MAFIA I LOVE MAFIA TYSM SLAY MAS

4) NO WHY ME NOOOOOOOOOO
Being on the villager team is easier because you're in the mindset of "ok i have to find the mafia, who is acting weird and why are they saying/doing un-townly things"
Now that I'm a murderer, I have to actually play harder to win and the risk is higher because if we lose there's a greater chance of myself going to the DM. Also you're in the mindset of "omg am i doing something that could be perceived as weird?"

I've seen that literally anyone can be voted off for the dumbest reason and if people bandwagon on the vote you're screwed. So if you give any player a reason to vote you, you get yourself in a hole that is hard to get yourself out of.

5) So either aggressively claim as the detective and accuse non-murderers as a murderer to get the numbers majority asap.
Or lay low, take a back seat and only take action when the opportunity to vote a villager to the jail presents itself.

Definitely leaning towards taking the aggressive detective claim approach, but the timing of it being on the 1st or 2nd round is very important.

I am hoping my teammates will be active enough to discuss or else we're so fucked. We do get a killing action at night, but if its nullified by the doctor and the rest of the team is inactive I have to fight off everyone else by myself and that's gonna be scary and frustrating.

[Joseph]

mas does the murderer decision on who to kill have to have all 3 of us in agreement???

what happens in the event that 1 or more people do not respond?

if I do end up being the only active person in the murderer chat, can I solely choose who to kill off?

[Bandage Man]

May 27, 2017 21:48:22 GMT -5 Joseph said:

mas does the murderer decision on who to kill have to have all 3 of us in agreement???

what happens in the event that 1 or more people do not respond?

if I do end up being the only active person in the murderer chat, can I solely choose who to kill off?

yes, it has to be a consensus. if not respond, will follow the opinion of whoever responded. if you are the one, you make the sole choice. if the remaining murderes does not respond, no murder will take place.

[Joseph]

mas, i want to tell you here because i don't want this to be a factor in getting picked for the DM.

But i will be traveling from June 1st - June 5th and will have limited access to the forums (mobile only so I can't really participate)

If I do end up playing in the DM I will let the rest of the cast know.

[Joseph]

I'm actually flying from now until the next 24 hours so I won't be able to access the forums either.

[Bandage Man]

Ok. Will take note if you survive

[Bandage Man]

Questions:

1) How did you find the Main Match?

2) With the Main Match breaking you all up into two groups, does it skews your plans if you had worked with people from the other group previously?

3) How do you feel being one of the losers?

4) Anybody you would have targeted if you were the winners?

5) How do you feel about your chances being in the Death Match?

[Joseph]

mas, I would like a room with me and plat.

And a separate room with myself and Joshua.

[Joseph]

1) I play mafia all the time online so I thought I would win, but I played too conservatively/complacent and with ethy as the sherif these 2 strategies were not compatible at all.

2) It didn't screw up my plans at all because since we all had the same win condition there was no reason to betray. So I could work with these people in good faith.

3) I feel like shit, but I just have to remind myself it's just a game.

4) I would have targeted Trevor no matter what since Kevin has told me him and Ethy have been tight. So it would be an indirect attack on ethy since I fear him as a player as much as Lukas now.

5) I think my chances of being in the DM are pretty high because I haven't been to the DM yet. So even if I'm not picked as the DM candidate, then whoever is the DM candidate will probably pick me with that justification anyways. Kinda hoping I participate as a DM player so I can selfishly postpone the game since I'm on a trip run .

[Joseph]

Mas, I cannot make any threads in the room with myself and Plat