Main Match #5...

[Bandage Man]

Please remember to discuss and if you all have a consensus, you can post it on the Main Match and don't need to wait for me.

[rexxefa]

I'm thinking of sending Joseph because:
1) He's the only one to never been on a DM out of those three
2) Lukas and Arnold each have 5 garnets. If both went to the DM, the winner will get 10 garnets and will have a major advantage if the next MM is a garnet match

[ethynol]

Yeap sounds good to me. I'm open to inputs from everyone. Personally, I felt that thats the best thing to do for now, and let Joseph who have not been to the DM to pick his own candidate.


Once again, Thanks for trusting in my and being my meatshield. Esp to you Plat!

[rexxefa]

By the way, congrats for the 5/5 wins Ethy and Kevin

EDIT: and I guess I have to make it clear that I do vote Joseph to be in the DM if we're going for majority vote

[platypus09]

yeah sending joseph sounds good to me, especially since he's the only one who has not been to DM. i'll vote for joseph as well.

[kaycali86]

I Vote Lukas.  

Strictly about this Main Match - On round 1, it was Ethy just outting himself as constable.  If he was Killer, it would have been a real huge mistake, but he wasn't.  Lukas doubting Ethy on round 1 - I was able to deduce right away that he was the killer.  Had he not even posted any doubts on round 1 or just accepted Ethy as the constable, I would have never drew suspicion towards him, where as both Arnold & Joseph didn't arouse suspicious like Lukas did early game.  

Secondly, Joseph not going DM - he'd still have 3 garnets.  There is going to be another garnet match or two in the future rounds, and we all have garnets way ahead of him.  So even if Arnold/Lukas where sent and had 10 garnets, it'd still be Joseph with the lowest count.

Also, yes Joseph hasn't been to the DM.  But he didn't do anything wrong this main match, as did Arnold.  Arnold was checked 2nd round, and Joseph kept the charade of being villager without raising suspicion.

So that's why i'm placing my vote on Lukas. 

[rexxefa]

I agree with your input Kevin, but I'm scared that if there are any different vote and we didn't reach consensus by the deadline, they will become the winners of the match and we'll be the losers. I was hoping that we could just come up with some name so that we'd be safe.

[ethynol]

Hmmm I guess you have a point there, although I didnt read that much into his action. From my little experience of playing Murderer, I cant seem to tell what people are doing, and hence I was always in a tossup during the process. All my moves I did was trying to 'get some response', but somehow the information provided doesnt seem very telling, and I have to make guesses and throw in new ideas to fish for more information. But yes, I have to admit that Joseph played the best out of the three of them.

As for the garnet issue, if that happens and if they have an garnet advantage it would help them for future MM and garnet matches, so I dont know whether that is a good thing or not..

Right now my vote is still up in the air, and I'm ready for discussion, but I'm okay with going both ways thats for sure!

[ethynol]

Let's wait for Trevor's and Joshua's input, and we can make a decision as a group.

Kevin - Lukas
Rexxy - Joseph
Ethy - ?
Joshua -
Plat - Joseph
Trevor -

[kaycali86]

Well if Joshua/Trevor don't post in time, then i['ll switch my vote to include majority. Is it majority? or we all 6 have to agree on one candidate before deadline? I'm confused. So let's say 4-2 Arnold for DM - is that by majority rule, or would Mr. Bandage Man think we didn't do a consensus and be losers?

Dead line is in 4 hours, so if Joshua/Trevor don't post in 3 hours, then we all get a consensus on vote. I'll be active

[rexxefa]

I do hope we could get a name quickly tho, just to get this over with

EDIT: and yea, I was wondering about that too... Hopefully Mas responds about that

[ethynol]

I can actualy vote now, just that I want to see if you guys have anymore inputs. I'll be there a couple hours before deadline to make sure there is actually an majority.

[abcdefg]

I'm voting for Lukas so it'll be Ethy and Trevor as the swing vote. I honestly have no preference at the moment.

[ethynol]

I'm going with Lukas then. Joseph played too well this round to be considered an elimination candidate.

I might switch if we need to get the majority.

[rexxefa]

Eh, what the hell...

Yea I'll change my vote to Lukas too. Hopefully trevor agrees to and plat could come back and change his vote